I remember the first date like it was yesterday. Every single detail is burned into my mind, a scar I can’t hide. I had been so nervous, so hopeful. He was charming, attentive, witty. Exactly what I needed after a string of duds. The restaurant was upscale, the kind of place I usually saved for special occasions. He made me laugh, truly laugh, and I felt a lightness I hadn’t felt in years. A small detail, but I remember it so clearly. When the bill came, I reached for my purse, just out of habit. But he waved me off, a confident smile on his face. He insisted on paying for everything. Not just the food, but the ridiculously expensive wine too. “My treat,” he said, his eyes sparkling. “Tonight is about celebrating you.” I felt a blush creep up my neck. What a gentleman. I thought, this could actually be it.
After dinner, he suggested a walk. The city lights twinkled around us, reflecting in the river as we strolled along the embankment. It was beautiful, idyllic. He held my hand, and I felt a warmth spread through me. We talked about our lives, our dreams, our pasts. Or, I talked. He mostly listened, asking thoughtful questions.
But then, the questions started to shift. They became… incredibly specific. He asked about my childhood summer vacations, about a tiny scar above my left eyebrow that I got falling off a bike when I was six. He mentioned my pet hamster, Captain Squeaky, who died when I was eight. Things I rarely, if ever, talked about. Things no one outside my closest family knew. Too specific.
My gut started to clench. A cold knot formed in my stomach. I tried to laugh it off, a nervous, brittle sound. “Wow,” I said, pulling my hand away. “You’re really good at getting people to open up! Are you a detective in your spare time?” He just smiled, a knowing glint in his eyes that sent a shiver down my spine. It wasn’t playful. It was… unsettling.
Are you retarded? | Source: Unsplash
Then he leaned closer, his voice dropping to a low, almost conspiratorial whisper. He mentioned my mother’s maiden name, a detail I’d never given him, a name only my closest family ever used. My breath hitched. My heart hammered against my ribs. I felt a sudden, desperate urge to flee. This wasn’t a charming date anymore. This was something else entirely.
I mumbled an excuse about an early morning, tried to pivot towards heading home. He took my hand again, his grip firm, unyielding. He looked at me, his eyes suddenly devoid of the earlier warmth, replaced by something I couldn’t quite place – sadness? Resentment? A profound weariness.
He started talking, his voice flat, emotionless. He spoke about my family, about my parents, about a specific period of time before I was born. He spoke about a secret, something my parents had desperately tried to bury, something they thought no one knew. My blood ran cold.
“They lied to you, didn’t they?” he said, his voice barely audible above the distant city hum. “About everything.”
Upset woman | Source: Pixabay
I tried to pull my hand away again, to deny it, to run, but I was frozen, paralyzed by an encroaching dread. He pulled out his phone, his thumb swiping across the screen. He held it up to my face. It was an old, faded photograph. A picture of my father, much younger, laughing with a woman I didn’t recognize. And cradled in her arms, a baby. The baby had his eyes, my eyes. The woman… she looked so much like my mother, but it wasn’t her. Not quite.
He pointed to the baby, his finger trembling slightly. “That’s me,” he said, his voice shattering into a whisper. “Your older brother. They sent me away. Paid my mother to disappear, to never speak of me again. All to protect their perfect little family.”
The world tilted. The city lights blurred. My mind reeled, grasping for purchase, for any logical explanation. This wasn’t real. It couldn’t be. This charming man, this perfect date…
Her dream house | Source: Unsplash
He looked me dead in the eye, that painful, weary glint back in his gaze. “And that dinner? My way of introducing myself. My way of saying, ‘Happy Birthday, little sister.'” A tear finally escaped his eye, tracing a path down his cheek. “Our birthday. We share the exact same birthday, just two years apart. The day they got rid of me. The day you became their only child.”
The realization hit me like a physical blow. My brother. My date was my brother. Everything they had ever told me about our family, about their perfect love story, was a lie. ALL THOSE YEARS. EVERYTHING WAS A LIE. And the most heartbreaking twist of all? That expensive dinner, that gesture of chivalry, wasn’t a romantic beginning. It was a painful, bitter anniversary. A brutal unveiling of a truth my parents had buried deeper than any grave.
